Accuracy of Cited References: The Role of Citation Databases

Robert A. Buchanan

Abstract

The nature and extent of errors made by Science Citation Index ExpandedTM (SCIE) and SciFinder® ScholarTM (SFS) during data entry have been characterized by analysis of more than 5,400 cited articles from 204 randomly selected cited-article lists published in three core chemistry journals. Failure to map cited articles to target-source articles was due to transcription errors, target-source article errors, omitted cited articles, and reason unknown. Mapping error rates ranged from 1.2 to 6.9 percent. SCIE and SFS also were found to correct errors made by authors in cited-article lists roughly one-half and one-sixth of the time, respectively.

Full Text:

PDF
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5860/crl.67.4.292
Copyright Copyright © The Author(s)


Article Views (By Year/Month)

2026
January: 27
2025
January: 16
February: 20
March: 29
April: 21
May: 20
June: 43
July: 30
August: 14
September: 24
October: 22
November: 28
December: 24
2024
January: 6
February: 1
March: 4
April: 6
May: 2
June: 1
July: 0
August: 1
September: 3
October: 4
November: 2
December: 0
2023
January: 8
February: 3
March: 3
April: 2
May: 0
June: 2
July: 1
August: 0
September: 2
October: 11
November: 2
December: 0
2022
January: 2
February: 2
March: 2
April: 5
May: 3
June: 4
July: 1
August: 1
September: 3
October: 5
November: 7
December: 7
2021
January: 5
February: 1
March: 4
April: 3
May: 2
June: 5
July: 2
August: 4
September: 2
October: 6
November: 5
December: 2
2020
January: 6
February: 10
March: 4
April: 4
May: 4
June: 1
July: 5
August: 2
September: 1
October: 3
November: 4
December: 3
2019
January: 2
February: 3
March: 4
April: 6
May: 11
June: 2
July: 6
August: 4
September: 9
October: 8
November: 5
December: 1
2018
January: 4
February: 4
March: 9
April: 8
May: 13
June: 8
July: 6
August: 7
September: 5
October: 2
November: 2
December: 2
2017
April: 1
May: 2
June: 6
July: 3
August: 6
September: 12
October: 9
November: 11
December: 5